Gooey Caramel Sauce

Total Time
15 mins
15 mins

This caramel is very rich and gooey. It can be thinned with a little water to make a sauce for ice cream or it can be used as-is for a gooey candy filling. Great with apples too! Recipe can be doubled. Because the sugar can turn from caramel to burned rather quickly it is best to have all ingredients measured before starting.

Skip to Next Recipe




  1. Heat 1/4 cup sugar in a stainless saucepan on medium heat, do not stir until sugar begins to melt.
  2. Once sugar begins to melt, stir it until it has completely melted and begins to turn golden brown.
  3. When sugar has started to turn caramel colored, remove pan from heat and immediately add butter and brown sugar and quickly stir together.
  4. Once the butter and brown sugar are completely melded with the caramel (add gentle heat if needed to incorporate brown sugar), add the vanilla, corn syrup, cream and salt.
  5. Stir together well.
  6. The caramel will thicken as it cools.
  7. If a thinner caramel is required, add water one tablespoon at a time until the desired thickness is reached; if a thicker caramel is needed, reduce the amount of corn syrup used.
Most Helpful

This is Great! I had just jotted down the directions, and failed to completely melt the white sugar, so the finished product had sugar crystal balls in it. I simply strained it though a mesh strainer. It was wonderful. I'll definitely make it many more times. Hard to believe only three people have reviewed this tasty sauce!

5 5

Best Caramel ever. I've never been successful at making caramel before, but I made this! It is delicious and easy. Definitely will make again.

5 5

Verygood caramel sauce, This how caramel sauce should be gooey, sweet and buttery. Thank you.