Butterfinger Pie

Total Time
10 mins
0 mins

This chilled pie will be gone right before your eyes. I would buy 8 Butterfingers. One to crush on top of the pie. One to eat.

Skip to Next Recipe




  1. Mix first three ingredients together.
  2. Put it in pie crust.
  3. Chill.
Most Helpful

5 5

Try using other candy bars. Heath bars work great.

5 5

Boy, did this ever go over good!! This is the easiest and quickest pie to make! Everyone loved it! I used 7 candy bars, crushed all of them and saved some for sprinkling on top. It took about an hour to chill. The crunchy bits and the creamy Cool Whip was a great combination. Thanks Braunda, for another permanent recipe in my collection!

5 5

If you enjoy a light, fluffy, creamy tasting pie, this is the one for you! Beautifully presented with crushed butterfinger candy decorating the top and with my own addtion of fresh mint leaves to garnish each slice. Braunda, what a delightful combination and so very easy to make! Thanks for a wonderfully simple dessert!